I would like to make a complaint about Simon Cowell from X-Factor 7th November.
Firstly why didn't Simon judge Lucy & John & Edwards based on their performance to stay in the competition?
Simon has said to contestants in many episodes who are having to fight for survival, that judgment will be based on their performance –clearly Lucy's performance excelled compared to John & Edward.
He stated not 5 minutes before the sing-off that last’s nights decision would be based purely on that last performance and yet he back-tracked and stated that he would actually prefer to see the boys back.
Lucy has the stongest female voice in the competition! (which Simon himself said on Saturday night), her looks, star quality any many more attributes compared to John & Edward which means that yes she is talented enough to win this "Singing" competition, (which I now think is more of battle of the Judges than a Singing competion giving the real talented contestants a chance for their Dream Career of being a POPSTAR!) and yes Lucy is more talented than John & Edward.
The public may not have voted enough to save Lucy, but the whole point of the sing-off is to save the better act, just like Simon did when Danyl was in the bottom 2, the public also only vote on Saturday nights performance and are not given the chance to vote between the bottom 2. If Simon is willing to pull this trick then I think the public should be given the chance to vote again to save one of the bottom two.
I could not see myself buying any music from John & Edwared! but definitely can from Lucy.
X factor is just pointless now, its more about the judges and their petty comments and getting the ratings up – its isnt' about talent!! He wouldn’t have done that if it was his act in the bottom 2!!!
I shall now be switching over to the BBC to watch Strictly Come Dancing, a show which is actually about talent! Stephanie Dawson
0 comments